The importance of second chances.

A recent Employment Appeal Tribunal case Centrepoint Soho v Omaboe highlighted that some initial procedural discrepancies in dismissal can be rectified at the appeal stage.

An employee of some 9 years of service was dismissed on the grounds of lack of capability to perform the job role due to an ongoing sickness. The decision to dismiss was taken at a meeting, which the employee attended, but the employee was not warned that a possible outcome of that meeting would be her dismissal. A claim to the Employment Tribunal followed and the decision to dismiss was found procedurally unfair. As the employee had not been warned that the meeting would consider her dismissal, the correct procedure was not followed, which ultimately resulted in the adverse decision. The employee claimed that had she known of the potential dismissal, she would have presented further medical evidence that may have prevented her dismissal. The Employment Tribunal also ruled that the manner and timing of the dismissal also constituted discrimination arising out of the employee’s disability.

On appeal, the Employment Appeal Tribunal disagreed. The employee in fact was given an option to appeal her dismissal to her employer, which she did. The initial procedural breach was therefore cured by reason of the opportunity to appeal the initial decision. At the appeal, the employee did not submit any new medical evidence or indicative dates of return to work. The employer was correct to uphold the initial decision.

The finding on discrimination was also overruled as it was not part of the employee’s pleadings and the Employment Tribunal stepped outside of the employee’s claim.

The lesson to take from this case is the importance of following the correct procedure in dismissal. The employer failed to inform the employee of the dismissal as a potential outcome of the meeting. What could appear a minute breach to some resulted in the finding of unfair dismissal. Lucky for the employer, the correct procedure was followed regarding giving the employee an opportunity to appeal, which rectified the original breach.


Authors: Kiril Moskovchuk

Published: 21 Feb 2018


To ensure you are a real person signing up and to prevent automated signups (spamming) could we ask you to copy the letters and numbers shown below into the box.

(cAse SeNSItivE!)

There are no comments

Share this Article